W-2 Vs 1099-NEC: What Should You File?

Avoiding IRS penalties starts with proper worker classification. Whether a payer classifies an individual as an independent contractor or an employee determines the appropriate tax form, tax withholding procedures, and IRS compliance review.

This guide outlines the key differences between Forms 1099-NEC and W-2, clarifies the issuance requirements for each, and provides guidance on maintaining compliance with federal regulations.

Why Worker Classification Matters

Worker classification isn’t a choice under IRS common-law rules, you must determine whether the worker is an employee (W-2) or an independent contractor (1099-NEC). It is that status that drives payroll taxes, withholding, and audit risk.

Misclassification can result in substantial back taxes, interest, and failure-to-file penalties. IRS penalties are $60, $130, or $340 per form, based on when you file the correct form. If you intentionally ignore the rules, the penalty is at least $680 per form.

Misclassification can also trigger state audits, particularly in states with stringent labor regulations. W-2 forms are filed with the Social Security Administration (SSA), which shares them with the IRS; 1099-NEC forms are filed with the IRS (through IRIS or FIRE), not the SSA so using the wrong form can still trigger notices.

What Is Form 1099-NEC?

Form 1099-NEC reports nonemployee compensation. A payer must file Form 1099-NEC when it pays $600 or more for services in the course of its trade or business to a worker who is not its employee. If backup withholding applies, the form is required regardless of the dollar amount.

Generally, payments to corporations aren’t reportable on Form 1099-NEC. However, attorneys’ fees and payments by a federal executive agency for services (vendors) are reportable on Form 1099-NEC (box 1). Plus, nonprofit organizations and federal, state, or local government agencies must issue Form 1099-NEC when they pay $600 or more for services in the course of their trade or business (including payments to contractors, directors, or attorneys).

Key Boxes on Form 1099-NEC

• Box 1: Nonemployee compensation
• Box 2: Check this box if you made direct sales that amounted to $5,000 or more of consumer products for resale do not enter a dollar amount (you may use either Form 1099-NEC box 2 or Form 1099-MISC box 7, but not both)
• Box 4: Federal income tax withheld under backup withholding rules
• Boxes 5–7: State tax withheld, state/payer’s state no., and state income (state reporting only optional for the IRS)

What Is Form W-2?

Form W-2 reports employee wages and associated tax withholdings. File a Form W-2 for each employee if you:

• Withheld any income, social security, or Medicare tax regardless of wage amount, or
• You would have had to withhold income tax if the employee claimed no more than one allowance or no exemption, or
• Paid $600 or more in wages, even if no tax was withheld

For Form W-2, very limited exceptions apply (for example, certain election workers and certain foreign agricultural workers paid under $600). Because both the SSA and IRS use the form, mistakes can slow down refund processing or create SSA mismatch notices.

Key Boxes on Form W-2

• Box 1: Wages, tips, other compensation
• Box 2: Federal income tax withheld
• Box 3: Social security wages
• Box 4: Social security tax withheld
• Box 5: Medicare wages and tips
• Box 6: Medicare tax withheld
• Box 12: Codes for items such as retirement contributions and fringe benefits
• Box 13: Statutory employee, retirement plan, and third-party sick pay indicators
• Box 16: State wages, tips, etc.
• Box 17: State income tax

Forms W-2 must match payroll records precisely to avoid discrepancies with federal and state agencies.

1099-NEC vs W-2: Key Differences

When to Issue 1099-NEC vs W-2?

Consider these examples: a freelance designer earning $3,200 for project-based work, an attorney receiving $900 in fees, or a consultant paid under $600 but subject to backup withholding.

Form 1099-NEC applies to nonemployee payments, whereas Form W-2 applies when the individual meets employee criteria, such as a seasonal receptionist working under a company schedule or a salesperson with a guaranteed draw, a company vehicle, and employer-provided benefits.

Consider behavioral control, financial control, and the relationship no single factor decides worker status. Let’s take a deeper look.

The IRS’s Three-Factor Worker Classification Test

The IRS looks at the full relationship and weighs facts across three categories. No single factor controls the outcome.

• Behavioral control: The business directs how, when, and where the work is done through detailed instructions, set procedures, schedules, or required training this points to employee status.
• Financial control: If the worker bears unreimbursed expenses, invests in tools or equipment, offers services to the market, and can realize a profit or loss, the worker likely has contractor status.
• Relationship of the parties: Employee status is usually indicated when the arrangement is ongoing, includes benefits, or the work is central to the business.

Still cannot determine status? File Form SS-8 to request an IRS determination!

Deadlines, E-File Mandate, and Aggregation Rules

Add up all payments you made during the year to each payee under the same EIN to see if you reach $600 for Form 1099-NEC. Remember not to combine across different EINs.

If your combined total of information returns plus Forms W-2 is 10 or more, you must e-file them all. Paper filing is allowed only with an approved Form 8508 waiver from the IRS.

For the 2025 tax year, the due date of January 31, 2026, falls on a weekend, so the deadline to furnish worker copies and file both Form W-2 and Form 1099-NEC is February 2, 2026.

Neither form has an automatic filing extension: W-2 filers must request a 30-day, non-automatic extension on Form 8809. Form 1099-NEC also has no automatic extension.

Penalties and Correction Playbook

Correcting errors promptly helps limit penalties and ensures accurate reporting.

FAQs

1. Can a worker receive both forms?

Yes. A worker may receive a W-2 for employee wages and a 1099-NEC or 1099-MISC for separate services or royalties.

2. Do incorporated contractors receive Form 1099-NEC?

Usually no, except for attorney fee reporting and certain federal agency payments.

3. Is withholding required on 1099-NEC payments?

Not generally. Backup withholding at a flat 24% applies only in specific cases.

4. What happens if a contractor should have been an employee?

The IRS may assess unpaid FICA, FUTA, interest, and penalties, and require reclassification.

5. Do reimbursements count toward the $600 rule?

Count them only if not adequately accounted for.

6. Are foreign contractors subject to 1099-NEC?

Generally no. Use 1099-NEC only for U.S. persons. Foreign contractors are reported on Form 1042-S when applicable.

Final Thoughts

Get worker status right before you file. Payments to employees belong on Forms W-2, while independent contractor payments belong on Form 1099-NEC. Classify correctly using the 3-factor test behavioral control, financial control, and the actual relationship. Once you know which payments go to which form, use Tax1099 to validate TINs in real time, catch errors early, and e-file Forms W-2 and 1099-NEC.

Avoid penalties and stay compliant

Start Filing with Tax1099 Today